Rooftop vs. Unplanned Sit.(MLE) & Ped. Hidden

[jdtimi]

Situation: opponent draws Unplanned Situation(Event)(an MLE card) and it comes into play. He has the location Rooftop already in play.

Unplanned Situation says "Both players must take the top Situation from their Endurance and place it into play."

He puts Masters Advice into play. My top situation is Ped. Hidden.

Rooftop says "While on the Rooftop no Pedestrian or Bystander cards may be played."

Since Unplanned Sit. says 'MUST' and 'PLACE it into play', I'm thinking it breaks the rules for Rooftop, since Rooftop was already in play. Besides, Rooftop says no cards 'MAY BE PLAYED'.

Does Ped. Hidden stay in play?

Ideas? Opinions? Rules lawyers...

Jeff Timi

[jamesmcmurray]

It stays in play. Putting a card into play and playing it are different things.

[abshock]

LOL, well I am 0-2 on rules questions from this tourney

[Thorr]

PEd hidden stays in play.