Insightful Planning (Before) vs. Master's PReparation

[ultra]

Love these few and far between out-of-turn cards. (assuming that' show the Insightful planning works)

So the Insightful Planning can or cannot stop the Master's PReparation?

Pretty sure it can, as im assuming the Insightful planning never goes "into" play to get nullified by the Master's Prep.

Generic Insightful Planning (Before) (AVD020) Alex Raven vs. Damon Case Fixed
Edge 1 [Empathy]
Text
REMOVAL: If this card is in your Hand, you may remove it from the game to counter an Edge, Special card, or Illusion played by your opponent prior to their Defense Phase. You may not increase the Restriction number of this card.

Generic Master's Preparation (CVT-000) Old Carl vs. Thomas Sullivan Fixed
Edge 2 [2E Only] [Master][Agility]
Text
Play only during your May Do / Must Do Phase.

Choose one in-game, non-gridded card type. All cards in play of that card type are nullified while this card is in play. This card cannot be nullified.

[dragothebreaker]

Do they have masters can’t be countered in pre game would be first question
- if yes, the no can not be countered


Second would be did they name edge
- this one is above me. - put will note how I would rule: If no masters can’t be countered I would rule yes it can be - however I could be wrong and would also say you must do so in your May do must do phase.

Hope this helps

[nkeates]

My take on this.
Master’s prep nullifies all cards of a certain type (edge cards in the example) that are in play.

Insightful planning is in your hand (not affected by Master’s prep). It is then removed from the game (not affected by master’s prep) . From the text it never actually enters play - it is removed from the game from your hand. So it can be countered by Insightful planning.

So I would agree Insightful planning would work against master’s prep unless your opp has MCBC in play.

Best

N

[ultra]

yeah. except if MCBC present. (i discount this pre-game card a lot).

[dragothebreaker]

MCBC is massive… especially for dark Duncan which people forget